When I become a minister I will make a dvd-library of Christian films for the parishioners to borrow so that they do not have to watch movies that have no real message. Until then you can watch many great movies for free legally on iTBN Network: http://www.itbn.org/search/index/page/1?search%5B%5D=movies&search_opt=or&airDate=&programs%5B%5D=Movies
I would recommend the following (click on title to watch):
The Theory of Everything: Dr. Holland is on a mission to prove the Holy Grail of physics – The Theory of Everything – that may prove the existence of God.
The Perfect Stranger: Based on the novel, ‘Dinner With a Perfect Stranger’ by David Gregory, ‘The Perfect Stranger’ tells the story of Nikki, a troubled attorney who one day receives a mysterious dinner invitation from a man claiming to be Jesus of Nazareth. Throughout their evening of conversation, arguments and spirited debate, Nikki learns things she never knew about life, the universe, and most importantly, herself.
Another Perfect Stranger: ‘Another Perfect Stranger’ (based on David Gregory’s second novel) takes up the story of the Cominsky family ten years after the first film ended.
Fireproof: A heroic fireman locked in a failing marriage accepts his father’s challenge to take part in a 40-day experiment designed to teach both husband & wife the true meaning of commitment in this faith-based marriage drama starring Kirk Cameron and Erin Bethea. (a trailer/song that fits is this one: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IwQhOpWcf4A)
Faith Like Potatoes: A true story of a rugged South African farmer, Angus Buchan, who wrestles with faith, hope, natural disasters and tragic personal loss
Hidden Secrets: Hidden Secrets is a story of love, friendship, redemption and ultimately faith. Humorous, touching and always entertaining
The Perfect Gift: What if the world threw you a birthday party…and you weren’t invited?
If I find more christian movies legally online I will let you know!